Of Love and Pies


Children - Picture Book
34 Pages
Reviewed on 12/22/2021
Buy on Amazon

This author participates in the Readers' Favorite Free Book Program, which is open to all readers and is completely free. The author will provide you with a free copy of their book in exchange for an honest review. You and the author will discuss what sites you will post your review to and what kind of copy of the book you would like to receive (eBook, PDF, Word, paperback, etc.). To begin, click the purple email icon to send this author a private email.

Author Biography

Sheila McGraw is the illustrator of the children's classic, Love You Forever, and she has illustrated and/or written many children's picture books and craft books. McGraw was born and raised in Toronto. In 2006, she permanently swapped Canadian snow for Texas sunshine, where she lives in a waterfront community in Galveston County. She is the mother of three grown sons.

    Book Review

Reviewed by Bonnie DeMoss for Readers' Favorite

Of Love and Pies by Sheila McGraw is a delightful and engaging children’s book that asks the question, Can you say “I love you” too much? What would happen if you said “I love you,” “every minute or two?” And what would happen if every time you said, “I love you,” multiple pies were baked? Would the streets be overrun with pies? Would pie suddenly become less special? Would there be so many pies that even a giant couldn't eat them all? What should you do? McGraw provides a wonderful story-poem to answer that question, accompanied by her own colorful illustrations.

Of Love and Pies will keep children and their parents laughing and entertained. Lively and imaginative, this captivating story-poem and the talented Sheila McGraw’s own whimsical illustrations make for a joyful read. This book describes and illustrates vivid scenarios where there are so many pies everywhere that they are literally underfoot. The characters are colorful and magically drawn. The picture of the pies reaching up to the moon is fantastically delightful. The problem is made apparent, and then a creative and heartwarming solution is offered. Does this mean you have to stop saying “I love you?” Of Love and Pies is a great story for parents to read to their kids. It will not only entertain but will also help teach problem-solving skills to children. This charming book would be a great bedtime read for parents and children, and is sure to end with "I love you."

Carolina Restrepo

Of Love and Pies is a beautiful story of how, by the act of saying "I love you," pies are created and spread throughout the world. But what happens when a person says, "I love you," too many times a day? Thousands of pies appear all over the globe, filling people’s lives and surroundings. After a while, people become annoyed and exasperated with the number of pies in their lives; how long do they have to tolerate the pies? Protests arise between communities and laws begin to be written about the excess of pies. Everything becomes a metaphor for how much one loves to demonstrate their love for others. Should that love be silenced or not? Sheila McGraw brings to life a complex story on love and community.

I loved Of Love and Pies even though it is short. It made me think and analyze several aspects of it and life itself. Love is the strongest force in the world, and its constant spread is one of the things that make the world go round. The pies are also an intricate metaphor for community and society, the connection between people even though they are from different places and speak different languages. Love is the one thing that we know for sure we share with animals as a species; we understand so little, yet that is what keeps us close and related to other species. We think we understand love but we can’t avoid the truth - love is too complex for understanding and words; we all see and feel it differently. Thank you, Sheila McGraw, for this amazing story.

Emily-Jane Hills Orford

I can’t imagine having too many pies. But, perhaps like everything else, too much of any one thing can become overwhelming. How about too many “I love you’s”? Are the quantities of pies and the number of times someone says “I love you” connected? If so, there would be so many pies in the world that people would be playing in them, squishing their juicy goodness all over themselves and building pie trails far into the sky, perhaps all the way to the moon. Too many pies? Perhaps. There has to be a compromise, wouldn’t you agree? One pie for one “I love you” and restrict the “I love you’s” so there aren’t too many pies. We can always feel the love; we just don’t have to say it all the time.

Sheila McGraw’s picture book story, Of Love and Pies, is a funny, pie-filled story about love. Or, perhaps it’s a love-filled story about pies. You choose. Told in rhyming verse and accompanied by charming illustrations, this gem of a story will entertain and amuse young readers of all ages as they compare the need for “I love you’s” with the need for more pies. The plot follows the supposition that the statement, “I love you,” equates to another pie for each time the statement is shared. And this makes the possibilities both outlandish and humorous. Like the nonsense verse of Dr. Seuss and the compassionate loving bond of stories like Robert Munsch’s Love you Forever, this story will capture our hearts more intensely with each reading. Beautifully told and funny, too. Personally speaking, though, can one really tire of either "I love you's" or pies?